The Worst Medicare Advantage Plans in 2023

In this article, we’ll look at some of the worst Medicare Advantage plans available in 2023, how they differ from the original, and which plans are the best choice for seniors.

If you are on Medicare, you can shop for plans that fit your budget and medical needs. However, if you are not careful, you may end up with a plan that doesn’t offer enough benefits or may even charge you more than other plans. The difference between the best Medicare Advantage plan and the worst can be minor.

Medicare Advantage plans have exploded in popularity over the past decade. Still, there’s a problem: they can be confusing and difficult to understand. This guide will give you the inside scoop on your area’s best Medicare Advantage plans. You’ll get an honest assessment of their pros and cons and learn what you must look for to choose the right one.

The biggest complaint about Medicare Advantage plans is their high out-of-pocket costs.

Medicare Advantages plans pocket costs

One of the most significant drawbacks of Medicare Advantage plans is that they lack freedoms and have high out-of-pocket costs.

Consider the monthly premium for a Medicare Supplement plan, and you could spend thousands on coverage that would outweigh what you would pay to enroll in one. Medicare Advantage plan premiums in a state are to what large employer plans in the state charge the average worker for individual coverage. Their plans are highly rated, featuring economical premiums with supplemental benefits, likely contributing to their sizable Medicare Advantage enrollment.

Medicare Advantage plans have high out-of-pocket costs. However, there are ways to reduce them. Some include enrolling in Medicare Part B (medical) before you turn 65.

Health insurance coverage for 2023. We are enrolling in Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) before 65. Part A is hospital insurance and generally covers skilled nursing facilities and sometimes nursing homes.

There are lower copays and higher deductibles with Medicare Part B (medical). You can avoid this by enrolling in Medicare Part C (Medicare Advantage program). Compared to the standard Medicare Part D plan, this includes a prescription drug benefit, so you won’t need to pay for your medication. Medicines filled at a pharmacy will be covered under Medicare Part D and your plan’s prescription drug coverage. a Medicare prescription drug plan is a good idea for many seniors.

Disadvantages of Medicare Advantage Plans

The disadvantage of Medicare Advantage plans is that they cost a lot of money. However, you will usually get a discount on your medical care if you pay a monthly premium. Still, you will also have to pay extra for certain services.

For example, if you have a plan from United Healthcare, you might have to pay a higher deductible. If you have a Blue Cross or Humana plan, you may have to pay a higher coinsurance rate for your medical care. However, some Medicare Advantage plans offer a meager cost.

Overall best Medicare Advantage provider: Humana

Medicare Advantage provider Humana

For 2023, Humana has been named U.S. News World Report’s Best Insurance Company for Medicare Advantage based on three criteria – best company for overall Medicare Advantage plan rating, best company for member experience, and best company for the availability of low-premium Medicare Advantage plans.

Humana is the overall best Medicare Advantage provider. They have been voted the top company for the last three years. Humana was the first company to offer Medicare Advantage plans. The Humana Medicare Advantage plan has a rating of 4.8 stars from 8 million reviews.

Are Some Medicare Advantage Plans Free?

Medicare Advantage plans free

Medicare Advantage plans are generally costly. If you are looking for a Medicare plan that is free or cheap, then you should look elsewhere. Many people don’t realize that Medicare plans come in several different levels, and the price of the plan will depend on how much coverage you want.

Some Medicare Advantage plans are free. There are many Medicare Advantage plans that are free. About half of all Medicare Advantage plans are free. This includes most Medicare Advantage plans from WellPoint, UnitedHealthcare, Humana, and Aetna. But not all Medicare Advantage plans are free. 

Check with your local Medicare office to determine if your plan is free. Many Medicare Advantage plans require you to pay a monthly premium. So make sure you understand what you are paying before you sign up.

Insurify Composite Score: 81.71 (Tie)

The Care One Plus plan offers many advantages to patients enrolled in it. By becoming a member of the plan, you can pay for a routine medical checkup and a preventative exam within 30 minutes. In addition, there are no copayments for diagnostics or lab tests.

Inpatient treatment for ill people can have the lowest costs, making these plans the top of our list. You also receive an excellent hearing, vision, and dental benefits during routine treatment.

A Review of Medicare Advantage vs. Original Medicare and Medigap

Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare are both forms of Medicare insurance. However, Medicare Advantage plans offer additional benefits over Original Medicare. For example, Medicare Advantage plans may cover prescription drug costs, dental care, vision care, and hearing aids.

Medicare Advantage plans can also offer more flexibility in choosing doctors and hospitals. For example, suppose you seek additional coverage for prescription drugs, dental care, vision care, and hearing aids. In that case, a Medigap plan might be right for you.

List of the top-rated Medicare Advantage plans by state.

Medicare Advantage plans are insurance products offered through private insurers that work with Medicare. Plans are generally offered in place of Medicare Part A and Part B, providing additional benefits such as vision, dental, hearing, and prescription coverage. 

These plans are often referred to as Medicare Advantage plans. Still, they are not the same as Medicare Part C, a separate program covering additional services. 

While some Medicare Advantage plans are sold directly by insurers, others are sold through private Medicare Advantage organizations. Still, others are sold by Medicare Advantage brokers.

Medicare Advantage company with the most extensive network: Blue Cross Blue Shield

A Medicare Advantage plan may require referrals to specialists if the customer has a Medicare Advantage plan. Blue Cross Blue Shield’s provider network includes over 342,000 providers. These private Blue Cross Blue Shield plans must follow Medicare’s coverage rules.

Insurify Composite Score: 80.79

Besides generic medications, low copays are offered for doctor visits, diabetic supplies, preventive dental treatment, and diagnostic and laboratory services at competitive prices.

Vision, mental health, and rehabilitation services are included at no copayment. In addition, comprehensive dental benefits can be added for $117 per month.

High Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limits

An insurance policy with a high maximum out-of-pocket limit also called an OOP limit, requires patients to pay more for their medical bills than a plan with a lower maximum out-of-pocket limit. 

The insurance comes in the form of individual health insurance plans or employer-sponsored group health insurance policies. Healthcare costs are limited with some high OOP limits plans. Other plans cap your total healthcare costs at a certain amount. However, high out-of-pocket limits will increase your medical bills.

Plans with Questionable Provider Networks

Medicare Part D has an unfavorable provider network. As a result, Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has issued a notice about this plan. According to the notice, CMS has identified many providers that do not participate in the program’s provider network. It also says the plan covers only about 80% of the services these providers provide. As a result, the plan may be limited. Therefore, this plan is not recommended.

Ways to Offset the Gaps in Medicare Advantage Plans

It is best to enroll in and afford a Medigap plan. They eliminate all the concerns and costs above. However, if a Medicare Supplement plan isn’t an option, here are some ways to combat Medicare Part C’s disadvantages.

Cancer Plans

Even though Part B drugs aren’t all cancer-related, the most expensive can be. You will receive a lump sum payment if you are diagnosed with cancer. If you choose, you can use these funds to offset the costs of chemotherapy administered in your doctor’s office.

Hospital Indemnity Plans

For each day you are admitted to the hospital, the hospital indemnity plan will pay you either a lump sum or a daily amount. In addition to being relatively low cost, these plans can help beneficiaries offset their per-day hospital copays. Many Medicare Advantage members enroll in these plans to offset their inpatient hospital copays.

Insurify Composite Score: 79.63 (Tie)

The minimum monthly premium is $0; the maximum annual expenditure is $3500. In addition, the plan covers copayment for no-cost in-network visits to primary and preventive hospitals.

Medical assistance is available without being a network member. Only $20 per doctor’s appointment. Includes dental and vision care.

When I enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan, can I also enroll in a Medicare Supplement Plan?

You can enroll in a Medicare Supplement Plan later if you enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan first. For example, suppose you enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan before you become eligible for Medicare.

In that case, you will be automatically enrolled in your chosen plan. However, you can still change your Medicare supplement plan later. Harvard Pilgrim has sky-high rates for their Medicare supplement insurance and has a high number of poor customer reviews

Medicare Advantage Plans: Why Do Doctors Dislike Them?

why do doctors dislike them

There are several reasons doctors don’t like Medicare Advantage plans:

  1. They are costly. They use high-deductible insurance plans, which means your doctor has to pay for everything except for a percentage of the cost.
  2. They require patients to use a primary care doctor before seeing a specialist.
  3. They use a complicated network to choose their doctors and hospitals.
  4. They have complex rules and restrictions on what is covered under the plan.

What are the Worst Medicare Advantage Plans?

worst medicare advantage plans

Medicare Advantage plans are the health insurance plans offered by private companies that contract with Medicare to provide medical services. These plans usually offer more coverage than traditional Medicare or Original Medicare, which is part of the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program (FEHB).

However, the downside to these plans is that they typically do not include comprehensive coverage for certain healthcare costs. In addition, some plans may have high out-of-pocket costs, which means that you are responsible for paying a higher percentage of the cost of your health care.

In addition, you can lose some of your benefits if you move to a different plan. For example, if you enroll in a new plan within 31 days, you’ll retain your coverage under the old plan.

Insurify Composite Score: 78.38 (Tie)

As a result of the low-cost care available to Medicare beneficiaries, this plan has a low annual cost of $2900. Additionally, no copay fees are charged for Tier 1 and Tier 2 drugs.

There is no copay for dental and preventive visits to the doctor’s office. The major disadvantage is it does not cover hearing aids, but hearing test costs can be subsidized by $20.

The Real Disadvantage of Medicare Advantage Plans

The Real disadvantage of Medicare Advantage plans is that they can be expensive. That’s because private insurance companies sell the plans, not the government.

When private insurance companies sell insurance, they make money, not you. So, choosing a too-expensive plan might cost you more than what you would pay for a regular Medicare plan.

Can I drop my Medicare Advantage plan and go back to my Original Medicare?

You can drop your Medicare Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare. You may still have to pay a deductible and coinsurance. Still, you can always go back to your Original Medicare. The new Medicare law allows you to drop your Medicare Advantage plan.

Is It Better to Have Medicare Advantage or Medigap?

Having Medicare Advantage is a good option for people who are over the age of 65. The reason is that it is costly to pay for all of your medical expenses with traditional Medicare. To save money, Medicare Advantage plans cover most of your medical expenses while you are enrolled in the plan.

The main thing to remember is that Medicare Advantage plans don’t come with a deductible, so you don’t have to pay anything before you receive coverage. Medicare Advantage plans also have lower premiums than standard Medicare.

Pros and Cons of Medicare Advantage Plans vs. Original Medicare

Pros and cons of medicare advantage plan vs original medicare

There are pros and cons to both Medicare Advantage Plans and Original Medicare. The biggest pros to Medicare Advantage Plans are:

  • Usually lower out-of-pocket costs.
  • No deductible.
  • It is being able to choose your plan.

The biggest con to Medicare Advantage Plans is that it takes a lot of paperwork. Original Medicare is more complicated but usually has a lower out-of-pocket cost. In addition to the pros and cons, there are other differences. There are three different ways that you can get Medicare Advantage Plans. You can be automatically enrolled in a Medicare Advantage Plan or opt into one. 

You can also enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan through your employer. You will have to do some research before choosing which option is right for you. If you choose a Medicare Advantage Plan, consider whether you want an HMO or a PPO.

Eligibility for the Initial Coverage Election Period

Suppose you are eligible to enroll in Medicare for 2023. In that case, you may be eligible to elect an initial coverage period of up to three months. This election period applies to the period starting on or after January 1, 2023, through September 30, 2023. On the other hand, suppose you are not yet eligible for Medicare but meet the initial coverage election period requirements. In that case, you may be eligible for this period. 

Final Thought

Final thought

It’s important to remember that when you shop for Medicare Advantage plans, you are making a financial decision, not just choosing a health plan. Before you pick an insurance plan:

  1. Take some time to consider each plan’s costs and benefits.
  2. Decide which option best suits your needs and budget.
  3. Remember that Medicare Advantage plans they vary in their networks, costs, and benefits.

It’s essential to compare plans carefully to get the best value.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement?

In addition to Medicare Parts A and B, Medicare Advantage is a private insurance offering vision, hearing, and dental coverage. Most Medicare Advantage plans also provide coverage for prescription medications (Part D).

A Medicare supplement plan, commonly called a Medigap policy, can fill in some of the gaps in Medicare coverage. Long-term care, dental, vision, hearing aids, private-duty nursing, and glasses are rarely covered by these policies. Despite being regulated to offer uniform benefits among providers, they are sold by private insurance companies, so they cannot be used for Medicare Advantage plan copayments, deductibles, or premiums.

Who regulates Medicare Supplement plans?

The federal government and the federal insurance department of your state both control Medicare supplement plans.

When does Medicare Supplement open enrollment take place?

Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment begins the first month you are covered by Medicare Part B and at age 65. It takes six months to complete the initial enrollment process.

Leave a Comment